Transcript 0:00 [singing] Oh, baby. Welcome to Lunch with Jamie, the series where I sit down with thought leaders and have meaningful conversations about hot button topics with a live virtual audience. 0:13 To participate in these online conversations and be in the room where it happens, subscribe to be a paid member on jamieslist.com. 0:20 You'll also be able to ask questions, participate in the chat, and get up-to-date information from my guests in real time. 0:27 [upbeat music] On today's episode, my guest is Georgetown law professor, Supreme Court expert, and diehard Mets fan Steve Vladeck. 0:36 We spoke about the recent SCOTUS rulings on the Alien Enemies Act, how the public should react to the law firms who bend the knee to Trump, the government ignoring court orders, his Substack One First, and much more. 0:48 With everything that's going on right now, it was great to sit down with Steve and make sense of it all. Enjoy. This conversation couldn't be more timely, as I've relayed to you guys. 0:58 Um, when I, uh, think about, uh, this idea of, like, muzzle velocity these days that Bannon threw out, and it's like every morning you wake up, you're just getting hit with so many different topics. 1:08 You never know what's gonna be the thing that's most topical, uh, and I'm always trying to figure out guests that can help us with that. 1:15 Uh, the judicial system is smack in the middle of that right now, and I have been trying to find the right person to talk to us, and Steve Vladeck is, without a doubt, the most important person that we could have to help us, uh, make sense, if he, if he can make sense, of what's going on. 1:34 And, uh, I, I assume most of you are signed up for Steve's Substack called One First, but if you're not, please do. Uh, please pay for it. 1:43 Uh, we, we know that the news, uh, is under attack these days, and trying to get news is next to impossible. 1:51 Uh, I personally sign up and pay for every Substack I can of anybody who is putting themselves out there, doing work. 1:58 It takes time, it takes effort, and if we wanna get real information and real facts out to people, we need to support people like Steve. 2:07 So, uh, I wanna put a link in the chat, and please make sure you sign up and, uh, and support him and share that with people. As most of you know, Steve is a law professor of Georgetown. 2:18 He wrote a book called The Shadow Docket, uh, and shockingly, he's a Mets fan, which is maybe the most- [laughs]... confusing part about him. Um- We're seven and three, Jamie. Just want- just putting that out there. 2:30 I know. You can't make that Mets joke as much anymore. It used to be such an easy joke to make. Now they- now they're actually good, so, um... 2:38 Uh, but, uh, Steve, before we, uh, get into this, the, the meat of our conversation, I am a foodie first and foremost, um, and I, I gotta get a little bit of your DC favorite f- restaurants these days. 2:52 Uh, so could you, could you give me one or two places that you love, or that if I was coming to DC, where would you take me? 2:58 Uh, so I'm embarrassed to say, Jamie, you know, we have two little kids, um, and so my favorite restaurant is any place that will make them plain pasta with butter and cheese. 3:07 Um, but, you know, not that long ago, we were, um, Karen and I were Rosa's Luxury fans. Um, we actually, we, we, we were pretty close to Aaron and BJ when they launched Rosa's Luxury about 12 years ago. 3:19 Um, so, you know, that sort of universe. Um, the, you know, the Neuman Tavern, which I know is just a, a New York transplant, but, uh, we've really enjoyed our meals there. 3:29 So when we can get out, which is seldom, [laughs] um, some of the old haunts, I think. Well, you had me at Rosa's Luxury. Uh, I think what she, what they do and at Maydan is, is pretty amazing. Yep. 3:40 Um, all right, well, it's hard to find things that are more important than, than what we should be eating, but, uh, we're gonna, we're gonna try. 3:47 Uh, so let's start off, uh, where you ended, you know, probably late last night or early this morning with today's Substack. 3:54 Uh, it's, it's really at the center of what's the m- most topical, uh, issue, which is the Alien Enemies Act right now. 4:02 Uh, so for the, the few people who didn't read this, this morning's issue, um, I'd love for you to, to just give us a sense of where this case stands and what you're expecting later today or in the coming days, and, uh, again, just thank you for being here and joining us. 4:18 Yeah, thanks for having me. 4:19 So, um, to sort of make a lot of really long story short, um, so President Trump has used the Alien Enemy Act to remove somewhere around 275 Venezuelans, uh, from the United States to El Salvador. 4:31 Um, so there were these two different orders that have been issued in the same case by Judge Boasberg in DC. Those orders are now gone. 4:38 I mean, those are the orders that the Supreme Court's decision last night gets rid of, which means at least, Jamie, as we're sitting here, there's no judicial ruling stopping the Trump administration, um, from using the Alien Enemy Act. 4:52 Um, there's language in last night's decision that says, going forward, if the administration wants to remove anyone under the Alien Enemy Act, it has to provide them with notice, and it has to provide them with an opportunity to challenge their removal in a federal court, um, and so we might see some of those cases coming soon. 5:11 But, you know, for the folks who have already been removed, Jamie, now we have this question of what happens to them. You know, can they be brought back? 5:19 Can the federal courts order the government to take whatever steps it can to get them back? Um, and that's really now an issue in a different case, um, called Abrego Garcia, which is before the Supreme Court right now. 5:31 This is the, um, the guy who was removed, uh, by accident, um, who is now trying to get, uh, back into the United States. 5:40 Um, a district judge ha- in Maryland had ordered that the government bring him back by 11:59 PM yesterday. 5:47 But, uh, Chief Justice Roberts, yesterday afternoon, right before the Alien Enemy Act ruling, had issued a temporary pause of that decision. 5:54 And so, you know, we expect the full Supreme Court to rule on whether the government has to bring this guy back.Jamie, maybe today, probably in the next couple of days, and that's gonna have a lot to say, not just about this poor guy, Abrego Garcia, but about the folks who have already been removed under the Alien Enemy Act as well. 6:11 Th- thank you for that, and thank you for, uh, laying it out so clearly. Uh, you know, I'm not... uh, my... I was a political science major, but my, uh, legal, uh, expertise is, is minimal. 6:23 Um, I had one question I was sort of putting towards the end of this chat, but I think I'm gonna just move it up to the front 'cause I think it's the, it's the most important one, which is 6:32 y- y- you know, we're living in a world right now which I assume that you don't teach in your law classes regularly, which is what do you do when the executive branch doesn't follow these rulings? And I... 6:44 you know, I've heard you talk about the one or two times in the history of the America where a president, uh, didn't abide by one of the rulings, but those were in, in s- slightly different situations. 6:57 How do you sort of lay out and, and look at the future when you're not 100% sure that the executive branch is gonna follow the rulings in the courts? Yeah, um, it's a big question. 7:11 So I think the short version is, um, [sighs] the first piece is to really make clear to everybody, including frankly the executive branch, just how dire the consequences would be if that happened, um, right? 7:25 And so it's not just about the president not following a court in one case. 7:29 Jamie, the federal government depends upon the federal courts every day, um, whether it's for criminal prosecutions, for civil enforcement actions, you know, for tax cases. I mean, right? 7:40 There, there's a universe of ways in which the federal government really cannot afford to get into a war with the courts, um, because even if Trump says in one case, "I'm not gonna comply with your mandates," you know, there are all these ways in which the courts can fight back. 7:54 I mean, a lot of folks online say, "Well, the president controls the Marshal Service." That's true, but the president doesn't control state bars, which can go after all of the lawyers in these cases. 8:04 Um, and the president can't make the judges hear the cases the federal government wants them to hear. 8:09 So I think part of the story for me is about making clear to everybody just how sort of m- complicated and multifaceted presidential defiance actually would be because of the repercussions it would provoke. 8:24 Um, if we get there, right, and I think there are reasons why we haven't gotten there yet, then I think the question is, is that the red line for enough Republican members of Congress? 8:35 Is that the point at which, you know, we see not even a majority of Republicans, but just, you know, a handful, 'cause that's all it would take in the House and the Senate to form majorities with the Democrats, where now we're talking about impeachment, where now we're talking about other steps to thwart the president's agenda as sort of retribution, as a lever because, you know, if that's not the red line, Jamie, I don't know what is. 8:56 So, you know, I think that's, that's how I try to think about the conversation. 8:59 I also think it's worth noting that even though we have lots of examples of the administration sort of slow walking compliance with court orders and, you know, in the Alien Enemy Act case, um, trying to sort of dance around whether or not it did or did not have to comply with that court order, it's striking to me that actually we don't see the president saying, "I don't have to comply with this." 9:21 And it's striking to me that we don't see, you know, sort of outright defiance. 9:25 It's almost as if it's better from the government's perspective to have this plausible deniability that, you know, they're not not complying, [chuckles] um, which I think drives home to that th- that even the White House understands just what kind of Rubicon it would cross, right, to, to take that step. 9:41 Right. Are you surprised at these, these acts that they're taking right now? I mean, are you shocked? I am surprised by some of this. I mean, a lot of it was in Project 2025, which, you know, I read. 9:56 Um, I, I guess what I'm surprised by, Jamie, is not what they're doing. I'm surprised at the lack of pushback from really any Republicans in power. 10:06 Um, you know, I would have thought that some of these moves would have already been the red line. 10:10 Um, so completely arrogating Congress's appropriations power, um, you know, I would have thought that someone like Tom Cole, the Oklahoma congressman who's the chair of the House Appropriations Committee, would be a little worried about, you know, the president basically taking over his job, um, and instead, you know, Representative Cole's response was, "Well, appropriations aren't laws in, in the first place," which by the way is not true. 10:32 Um, so I, I guess I'm not surprised at what they're doing. I'm surprised at how sort of few roadblocks they've encountered. 10:40 Um, and it's part of why, Jamie, we've seen so many, you know, head-on confrontations between the president and the courts because that's been it, um, right? 10:50 In any other administration, a president who tried to do even half of the things that Trump is trying to do would have met with such political pushback, um, you know, within his own party, from Congress, you know, from sort of other institutions that, yeah, there would have been litigation too, but Jamie, the litigation would not have been the full story. 11:08 Um, whereas here we really are all, or at least, you know, those of us who are sort of paying attention to the courts are sort of like desperately following each case because that really is all we have, and I think m- the best evidence of that is how much Trump and his supporters are attacking the courts, um, because they too I think understand that the courts are at the moment the principal thing standing in their way of accomplishing what they want to accomplish. 11:35 Going back to the Alien Enemies Act for a minute, um, were you, um... 11:41 I've heard this argument that, you know, the people who were deported, uh, you know, didn't deserve due process, um, and w- why do you think that's kind of fundamentally flawed? 11:51 Uh, obviously from kind of a moral perspective it's clear, but what are the legal ramifications of that and, and why do you... W- w- how... Explain that. 11:59 Yeah, I mean, so Stephen Miller even I think tweeted at one point, right? "Illegal immigrants are not entitled to due process." And, you know, my best response to that l-First of all, they are. 12:08 But even if that weren't true, um, how do we know they're illegal immigrants? 12:11 Um, right, I mean, the, you know, due process is what allows any of us to have confidence that when the government points to someone and says they are a member of MS-13, or they are a member of Tren de Aragua, um, that that's actually correct. 12:26 And so, you know, Jamie, I spend a lot of time in my law school classes, partly 'cause I teach civil procedure, which is the basic first-year process-heavy class, trying to help my students understand how you can have sharp disagreements on what the substantive policies should be, and sharp disagreements about what the substantive laws even are, and still think that due process is essential to reducing the risk of error, um, and to actually ensuring that the, the policies the government actually has are carried into place correctly, right, and not just as sort of whether through malice, Jamie, or just negligence, um, you know, not through mistakes. 13:05 Uh, yeah, seems so clear. Um, Trump, uh- I would've thought so [laughs]. Yeah. So as, um, Trump's floated this idea that, you know, some judges are bad judges, some judges are rogue judges, and- Yeah... 13:20 um, you know, and Mike Johnson even talked about this idea that Congress has the ability to eliminate entire district courts. Um, you know, is that actually possible? 13:31 Uh, and, you know, conceptually, you know, w- help me understand Trump's, uh, thought here, or logic, or rationale. 13:40 Yeah, I mean, listen, I, I, you know, I don't, again, I don't think it's surprising that, um, in the face of an unprecedented number of rulings blocking his policies, right, that Trump is lashing out at the courts. 13:52 Um, Congress does have a lot of power over the lower federal courts, so federal district courts and federal courts of appeals. Um, you know, it can't make these judges go away. 14:01 I mean, that's, that's what judicial independence is about. But it could... 14:04 I mean, Jamie, if you really pass the statute through both chambers and the president signed it, you know, you could pay these judges to do very little, right? You could take cases away from particular lower courts. 14:13 Um, what is striking about this conversation is both how, like, shamelessly hypocritical it is when we look back at what litigation looked like during the Biden administration, for example, when, you know, challengers to Democratic policies, um, didn't sort of go after s- you know, nationwide lawsuits. 14:33 They filed in, like, a small handful of very carefully picked courthouses in Amarillo, Texas, or Lake Charles, Louisiana, or Victoria, Texas, where they could handpick the judges, and get the same nationwide relief. 14:44 So part of it's hypocrisy. But Jamie, at a broader level, um, this is not a handful of judges who are ruling against Trump. 14:51 I mean, my research assistant and I, you know, put together the data as of, I think it's now, gosh, uh, 10 days ago. 14:58 Um, and 10 days ago, you had, uh, 46 r- uh, cases in which federal judges had ruled against Trump policies. 15:08 Those 46 cases came from 39 different district judges sitting in 11 different district courts in seven different circuits. 15:17 Um, and so, you know, when Trump says, "It's the judges, it's the judges," you know, I say, well, maybe it's the policies, um, right? 15:23 There's the, I don't remember whose line it is, but there's the old line about the guy who says, you know, "Everyone at work is an asshole. My boss is an asshole. My assistant's an asshole. My coworker's an asshole." 15:32 And the friend says, "Maybe you're the asshole?" Um, right? 15:36 Like, you know, this is, this is the problem with the, with this argument, is that, you know, we have federal courts for the purpose of holding the executive branch to account. 15:44 And when the president loses in lower courts, the remedy, as Chief Justice Roberts himself said a couple weeks ago, right, is not to attack the judges. 15:52 It's not to call them rogue judges, not to impeach the judges, just to appeal. 15:57 I, uh [laughs] you know, I've listened to some of these three-hour podcasts, and I'm sorry, how do you, how can you talk about something for three hours? 16:03 Uh, we're gonna be, we're gonna be, we might be here for three hours. 16:05 Um- [laughs] I, y- y- um, the, um, a h- a handful of people are talking about those, those issues related to the, the, um, uh, these law firms that are sort of, you know, I'll, I'll use the term of the moment, the bending the knee to Trump. 16:21 Um, you know, have, a, I'm curious, has, has anything like this happened before? And, and, b, uh, w- are, are you, are you sur- o- obviously you're surprised. I keep asking that question. 16:35 [laughs] And we're surprised, I guess we're not surprised by anything anymore. But are you, um... What, what do you think is gonna, we're gonna see happen going forward in relationship to those situations? 16:47 Do you see more firms doing that? And, and then in addition, how can people push back, in your mind- Yeah... and what are you suggesting people to do? Um, so I find the law firm stuff really, really serious. 17:01 Um, and, and, you know, I mean, I'm a lawyer, and I'm a law professor, so I'm, I'm naturally inclined to find that particular slice of the story especially significant. 17:09 But, um, part of why I find it so serious is because, you know, courts are reactive institutions, right? Judges don't go out and find cases. The cases are brought to them. 17:20 Um, and, you know, we have pro se litigants in our legal system. We have the ability for people to bring lawsuits on their own. 17:27 But realistically, you know, law firms are a bulwark because they're often in the best position to bring the kinds of lawsuits you need, Jamie, not for one-off misconduct by the executive branch, but for systemic misconduct, right? 17:42 That that's really where you need firms with resources, and reputations, and experience in these kind of spaces. And, you know, it's not just my view. 17:51 I mean, the Supreme Court has a case from 2001 called Legal Services Corporation versus Velazquez, where the court struck down a statute that had purported to bar the Legal Services Corporation, which gives out money to folks to represent, um, indigent clients. 18:07 Um, so Congress had tried to say, "You can't take the money we give you and then sue to challenge statutes we've enacted." And the Supreme Court said, "Well, no, you can't do that, Congress," right? 18:17 Like, the, the lawyer's job is to make good faith arguments under the law, and, you know, we depend upon that as much as they do.Um, so that's what I lose sleep over with all of the sort of threatening of law firms, which is it seems like a pretty transparent attempt not just to retaliate against these firms for constitutionally protected conduct but to chill them and to scare them and to cow them into submission. 18:41 And so, you know, what I'm surprised by, Jamie, is less that Trump is trying this. I'm surprised at the firms that have caved. Um, and, you know, I'll, I'll say that my surprise has come in sort of two different waves. 18:53 Um, I was surprised at the first round of cave in by Paul, Weiss, et cetera, but I was even more surprised by what we're seeing now. I mean, now we've seen a handful of firms very publicly fight back, right? 19:07 We've seen Perkins Coie not just sue the, the Trump administration, but actually, you know, have Paul Clement, the former George Bush solicitor general, represent them, right? 19:16 We've seen Jenner & Block sue the administration. We're seeing Covington, um, sue the administration, right? 19:22 The fact that there are firms after this, after we've seen big name law firms pushing back that are still, you know, to use your phrase, bending the knee, I think is even more alarming to me because I would have thought that once there was, you know, enough noise about pushing back, once there was enough attention to the firms that were pushing back, that would have given more of a backbone to the firms that were wavering. 19:47 Um, and the fact that it hasn't, I think is actually, you know... 19:51 I don't think it's like a five alarm fire 'cause I think that the firms that are pushing back are doing a really good job, and I think that, you know, establishing legal precedents that Trump can't do this will benefit all these firms. 20:02 But I'm really... I mean, it's, it's really disappointing to me that there are firms that are putting, you know, their... 20:08 what they, what they claim is their fiduciary obligations to their clients, um, ahead of, you know, their responsibility to the rule of law, which is something all lawyers have. 20:17 Um, and, you know, that might be easy for me to say as a law professor, but I think it's, it's something that has not gotten enough pushback and enough conversation, right, in this, in this debate. 20:28 And I guess my follow-up would be why do you think it's... why do you think they're doing it? Why is it not gotten attention? 20:33 And then the final thing, you know, you have people, uh, calling their representatives when they're upset about things. I mean, is- should people be flooding the phone call, the phone lines of these firms? 20:43 And I mean, what should people be doing to, to really push back? And is there a way to do a pushback? So, um, let me answer those questions in order. To the why it's happening, so take a firm like Paul, Weiss. 20:53 Um, I'm gonna make up some numbers, but, but I don't think that these are wildly off. 20:57 So assume that Paul, Weiss, um, which is principally a deal-making firm at this point, not a litigation firm, assume that like nine of their top ten partners by terms of how much revenue they're bringing to the firm, um, tell the, the executive committee that if they fight Trump, the partners are gonna, are gonna walk, right? 21:16 Because they have clients, and the clients can't afford to be represented in, you know, regulatory proceedings or before administrative agencies by a firm that's perceived to be hostile to Trump. Um, right? 21:30 So I can understand if that's the story why a firm like Paul, Weiss even thinks it's a close call, right, about whether to, you know, make a deal or not. 21:41 Um, I still think that you can't put, you know, sort of fidelity to the rule of law, um, a-against dollar signs, right? Like, these are not, these are not compar... uh, things that can be compared to each other. 21:53 And, you know, the nine-- the-- my, my hypothetical nine partners who are gonna bolt to another firm, well, if there's no firm for them to bolt to, right, if all of the other firms that they would otherwise go to, you know, have Paul, Weiss's back, um, then the story is different. 22:10 And so I think you-- some of this is a first mover problem. Some of this is a collective action problem. 22:15 Some of it's a problem that you don't-- that law firms don't have their own professional association that can sort of do all this on their behalf. 22:21 Um, but I think that's part of the conversation that has gotten us to this point, um, even if I still would have hashed out those, those values differently. 22:29 Um, as for what, you know, folks can do, I mean, those of us who are in a position to send work to law firms should be going out of our way to send work to the firms that are fighting back. 22:41 Um, and indeed to, to make the point that, like, we are hiring you because you are fighting and we want, you know, if we have bet the company litigation or if we have even a, a relatively modest case that we're dealing with or if we are on the board of a nonprofit, like, we want, we want fighters for our lawyers. 22:59 [laughs] Um, you know, obviously, not all of us are in a position to do that, but just sort of the more we can express support publicly, privately, through our business however for the firms that are doing this, um, and the more that we cannot support the firms [laughs] that are not doing this, I think that's, that's a message that will resonate. 23:18 I mean, I'll just say, you know, I've-- I am very good friends with the managing partner of the DC office of one of the firms that is fighting, and it has been enormously useful for that firm that they've gotten some new, you know, pretty significant clients, um, in the last couple of weeks, f- at least partly because they are visibly fighting, um, right? 23:38 Th- More of that. I don't have business to throw at them, but maybe they can send them all some, like, uh, donuts or something to, to thank them. 23:45 [laughs] You know, donuts, coffee, I mean, everyone, everyone takes their fuel in different ways. But, but, you know, just... And I, I think it's just, you know, 23:54 the more that it becomes, you know, like, these firms are doing good and those firms are not, um, right, the, the more that you'll be encouraging other firms that have to make this decision to make what at least to me is the right decision. 24:08 Well, not to give you more work, but I'd love to see the kinda naughty and nice list from these, these, uh, in the law firm. 24:15 So if you can point me to the direction to, to find that or where we can track that, uh, I think that's helpful, and people should be aware of it. And it does actually seem like something that's relatively easy to do. 24:26 Um, again, whether you're just sending a nice handwritten note or you're actually sending, you know, some real business, uh, I'm sure both will go a long way. 24:33 Um, I wanna go through a little bit of an, uh, a sort of thought experiment with you and get ourselves out of the, just the, the nonstop news for a second. 24:43 And the irony is that when I first started reaching out to so- to, to you and some other people about coming on to talk about the courts and the Supreme Court, it was-When Joe Biden was in office. 24:53 And so obviously, none of these topics were, uh, a part of what I wanted to talk about. And what I really wanted to talk about was the Supreme Court and the makeup of the Supreme Court. 25:03 And we have been talking, uh, and hearing about all these different things about how the court should be rethought, and should we add people, should we-- what, what should be done, term limits. 25:12 So my, my- Yeah...ec-- what I would love you to do for a second is i-imagine we're in a situation where the court, you are able to completely remake the court right now. You have the, you have the, the magic pen. 25:24 You have that big marker that Donald Trump signs everything in. You have that marker, and you can- I'm, I'm sending the hurricane to Alabama. Exactly. [chuckles] Yeah, exactly. 25:33 Um, and you can create the new Supreme Court that's going to be the law of the land going forward. What would your court look like? Ooh, um, that's a lot of power. 25:45 Um, so, you know, uh, let, let me give you sort of my, my academic answer to that question as opposed to my, you know, I live in a world where I want things to be different, um, um, answer to that question. 25:56 Um, I think that the principal problem with the Supreme Court we have today, and I thought this during the Biden administration, and I think it's very true today as well, is that we have a Supreme Court, Jamie, that to a degree we've never seen before, is not and does not think it ought to be accountable to the other institutions of government. 26:14 Um, right, we've had six-three conservative majorities before. We've had courts that were hostile to precedent before. We've had bad actors on the court before. 26:24 I mean, there's a, a justice who wouldn't even be in the same room with Justice Brandeis 'cause he was such a virulent anti-Semite. 26:31 Like, you know, we got through all of those prior periods because we also had a court that was in constant dialogue with the other branches of government. Congress controlled the court's docket. 26:43 Um, Congress controlled the court's budget. I mean, Congress used to use pensions as a cudgel to get justices off the court when they [chuckles] wanted to. 26:51 There's a, there are a couple statutes Congress passes to actually, like, entice, you might even say bribe, specific justices to retire, um, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. 27:00 Um, there's, Jamie, there were so many ways that Congress used to nudge the court, not to sort of rule in particular ways in particular cases, I think that would be a problem, but sort of to not get too out of, you know, kilter, to not get too out of line with the mainstream. 27:16 Um, you know, Paul Freund, who's a great, uh, con law professor at Harvard, had this quote that I love. 27:21 He said, "Justices, um, should be oblivious to the weather of the day, but they should be attuned to the climate of the age." 27:30 Um, meaning, right, like the judicial independence means ruling in any one case without fear of the direct political ramifications to you, but behaving as an institution in conversation with other institutions of government. 27:44 And Jamie, we have gotten so far out of line from that. I mean, Justice Alito had a quote in The Wall Street Journal in July 2023 that I couldn't believe. 27:53 Um, he said, uh, I, I wanna get this right, "I realize this is a controversial provi-- uh, uh, position, but I'm willing to say it anyway. 28:00 Uh, no provision in the Constitution gives Congress the power to regulate the Supreme Court, period." Um, that's literally false. 28:08 I mean, Article III, Section 2, Clause 2 literally says Congress can make regulations to the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction. 28:15 But forget that it's literally false, it's the mindset, Jamie, that they can do whatever they want without worrying about Congress, you know, passing new statutes or reigning in their jurisdiction or, um, you know, messing with the budget. 28:28 So if I could, you know, start over, I would actually use the model we had for the better part of a hundred and seventy-five years, which was a Supreme Court that did lots of bad stuff because, you know, justices are insulated from doing what we want them to do at every second, but an institution that was actually super responsible in not getting too far afield from where the mainstream political discourse was. 28:54 And Jamie, in the few moments where the Court really did, there was pushback. I mean, Reconstruction and, you know, 1937, um, there are actually powerful examples, right, of the Court 29:07 sort of course-correcting because of public pressure. 29:11 So that, so more than any one particular reform, like, that's what I think is missing, and that's what I would want to bring back, which is the Court doing its job while looking over its shoulder, um, to a degree that it just doesn't today. 29:24 I'm gonna push back on you, Steve. I want- Good. You need to remake the Court. What, how many justices do we have? Do we have term limits? 29:31 Do we-- What are the other, what are the other, uh, rules that you would im-i-impose? Okay. Um, so if we're doing this totally from scratch, right? 29:40 Um, so I want, um, 13 justices because we have 13 federal appeals courts, um, right? 29:48 And I wanna require that each justice come from the geographic domain of those appeals courts, which was a norm we actually used to follow, um, which would ensure geographic diversity on the court, something we never had before. 30:00 Um, Jamie, I want a, a professional diversity on the court. I want some non-lawyers up there. 30:05 You know, we had, um, some of the most effective justices in the court's history were not trained lawyers, they were politicians. 30:11 Um, you know, um, Jamie, I want term limits, um, not because I think that they're actually, like, this amazing salve to everything, but because I think if you had 18-year term limits with staggered appointments every two years, we would not have this push to appoint 45-year-olds to the court, um, right? 30:30 The-- We'd be more content with fifty-five and sixty-year-olds, um, right? And I think that would also create more stability with regard to the sort of when the court's gonna turn over. 30:40 Um, you know, I mean, I, there are lots of other things I would do. I would have Congress control more of the court's docket. So, you know, this is sort of a nerdy point that I think a lot of folks don't appreciate. 30:49 Until 1891, the Supreme Court had zero control over its docket. The Court had to hear all of the cases Congress told it to hear. 30:59 Um, that has totally flipped over so that today the Court has almost complete control over its docket. 31:04 You know, guys, it's not hard to figure out why a court that can sit back and pick the cases it wants is gonna pick cases that, you know, folks who are not aligned with the current majority are gonna hate.Um, versus having to decide the cases that the other branches tell you to decide. 31:18 It's a very different thing. 31:20 So Jamie, I, I guess to sort of take a half step back, there are lots of democracies that divide the functions of what we might call a Supreme Court of Appeals, the court that has to go last for the sake of uniformity from a constitutional court. 31:36 Um, right? For better or for worse, our Constitution blends those functions together. 31:41 I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing, but it has to be sort of moderated and policed so that the court doesn't skew too far toward one or the other. 31:49 So if I were in charge, that's where I would try to get us back to, is a court that was in a better, more stable, more predictable equilibrium, where, to quote Freund again, right, the justices could be immune from the weather of the day, but couldn't ignore, right, the climate of the era. 32:04 And I think the problem right now is that we have justices who think that they're immune from everything. 32:09 I, I love that, and for next semester, I'd like to see your, uh, you know, the re- the recreation of the Supreme Court class, and, and please sh- share the findings with it. 32:20 Uh, you know, it's, it's wild when you hear things that are so logical and make so much sense but just aren't being implemented, and I think, you know, some of the things you just mentioned, uh, uh, are, are that way. 32:32 And it's sort of shocking when you hear just that idea that Congress used to decide the docket. I mean, it's... That makes total sense. I mean, the idea- [laughs]... that's not the case, uh, is preposterous. 32:44 Uh, now, I've never... It never once crossed my mind 'cause I... That's not something I've studied. So, 32:49 uh, um, you know, one of the things that I've been surprised by, and I guess a little less now than prior, is that, you know, Trump at this point has three justices on the Court, uh, although it seemed that m- there have been a handful of times, and maybe more than, uh, more than not, where the Court's ruled against Trump and/or his sort of MAGA, uh, you know, principles or p- you know, ki- uh, uh, are you... 33:18 Is that fair to say, and, uh, have you been surprised by the justices he has appointed? Um, I think it's fair to say. I mean, I think it's, it's... 33:30 You know, having this conversation today is, makes me a little more circumspect because of last night's ruling in the Alien Enemy Act case and Friday night's ruling in the teacher training case. 33:40 Um, I, I guess what I would say is, and, and I'm gonna overgeneralize a bit, but I think this will be helpful. 33:44 Um, I think that you could largely sort most of the judges and justices on the federal courts today who have been appointed by Republican presidents into two loose categories, um, and for lack of a more sophisticated term, I'll call them Trump judges and Bush judges. 34:03 Um, right? And the key is which category you're in does not depend upon who appointed you, right? 34:09 It depends upon, you know, are you sort of a classic establishment conservative, um, you know, who came up with the federal society in the 1970s and 1980s, right? 34:20 Who's committed to sort of the consistent, coherent principles of the conservative legal movement, um, or are you a more populist, you know, do whatever Trump wants type of judge? 34:33 Um, and, and Jamie, you know, that's not a... That's a little bit unfair, but I'm generalizing. Um, I think of the six Republican appointees on the Court right now, you know, I think there are probably, um, 34:47 four, um, who I think of as, you know, pretty Trumpy, um, maybe three and a half, and two and a half who are, who are more Bushy. Um, right? 34:57 So I think, you know, Thomas and Alito I think are actually the closest thing we have to Trump judges on the Supreme Court. 35:03 Um, you know, I think Gorsuch, except for the handful of issues where his libertarian sensibilities prevail, has been remarkably Trumpy insofar as what he has and has not cared about and how he's ruled. 35:17 Um, and frankly, I think Justice Kavanaugh, um, has been at least a little Trumpier than certainly Justice Kennedy would've been. 35:24 Um, and in contrast, you know, I think the chief justice and Justice Barrett really are more in the classical Bush mold, which, you know, is I think maybe not surprising for Roberts and maybe a little more surprising for Barrett. 35:37 Um, but I think, you know, we have, I think, already memory hold the political circumstances of both, you know, Kavanaugh's appointment and Barrett's, right? 35:46 I mean, Kavanaugh was basically, you know, wheth- whether Justice Kennedy specifically said, "I'll only retire if you nominate Kavanaugh," or whether it was just a sort of much more subtle message, right? 35:57 Um, Kavanaugh was the intended successor to Kennedy, um, and, you know, Barrett was the only really obvious choice given the moment that Trump had, the brief moment he had when Justice Ginsburg died. 36:11 Um, and so I, you know, my own view is that when we look at all of the big cases the Supreme Court has today, we're at a point now where the most likely fourth vote to go along with the Democratic appointees in ruling against President Trump, um, is Justice Barrett, um, and that really it's the chief who's become the median again. 36:30 Um, and, you know, there will be cases, I'm sure, where Kavanaugh also rules against Trump, and it's really hard to believe that there will be cases where he's the fifth vote, um, against Trump versus the sixth. 36:41 Um, and I think that gets back to the sort of the, the difference between who are the sort of the Bush Republicans and who are the Trump Republicans. Right. That, that makes sense. Um, 36:51 you know, obviously we're, we're drinking from this fire hose of just sort of chaos in the courts and, and, and decisions that appear to be pretty awful. 36:59 Um, w- are there, have there been any decisions, you know, in, in, in the last couple weeks or things that kind of have, that have kind of given you some hope, um, about, uh, some of the cases, uh, or some of the... 37:12 Uh, whether it is in the Supreme Court or the federal courts, uh, any courts that you're seeing, what's, what's, what's making you kind of feel good about the courts today?I mean, I, I will say I have been really heartened by the reaction in the lower federal courts to a lot of what we're seeing. 37:26 I mean, I know, you know, especially for the folks who are not lawyers or law adjacent, it seems like litigation is slow, it seems like the courts aren't moving fast enough, it seems like their powers are limited. 37:38 Um, and I'll just say that I think, you know, compared to any other presidency in American history, we are seeing a more aggressive, more sustained, and faster pushback by the federal courts, um, than we've seen ever before. 37:51 Um, you know, that's-- th-there are, Jamie, I think some baked in limits on what the courts can do, but we're seeing, you know, judges appointed by both Republican and Democratic presidents all over the country, you know, ruling against a bunch of these policies. 38:04 Um, the complication is that when the Trump administration is seeking, you know, what the lawyers call emergency relief, basically to sort of not to conclusively resolve the case, but to have the status quo favor the government while the case goes forward. 38:21 Um, you know, so far the Supreme Court has been more acquiescent than I would have thought. 38:25 Um, and so, you know, Friday night, the court put back into effect, um, you know, the ruling in the edu-- in the teacher training grants case. Um, Saturday, right? 38:36 Uh, or sorry, yesterday, the court h- ruled in the alien enemy case. So Jamie, I, I'm, I'm heartened by what's happening in the lower federal courts. 38:43 I think we're still in the middle of figuring out where the US Supreme Court's gonna end up in the run of these cases. 38:49 And at least at the moment, you know, the, the court is, I think, doing more to let these policies go forward without actually blessing them than I at least would've preferred. 39:01 We all just watched the Wisconsin Supreme Court race unfold, and despite Elon Musk trying to buy the election, ultimately the more liberal judge, Susan Crawford, won. 39:12 What do you think some of the implications of that race are? So I'll just say, I mean, the-- I think the Wisconsin race is, [sighs] you know, a positive sign from the perspective of both, you know, sort of, um, 39:28 what that will mean, for example, if like the presidential election in twenty twenty-four is super close in Wisconsin. 39:35 Um, I think it's also a really positive sign that there was this real resistance to, you know, Elon Musk's attempt to really throw all of his money behind the Republican candidate and have that succeed. 39:47 Um, you, you know, we're at a point, Jamie, where state courts are really, really important, um, perhaps more so than, you know, we are used to when we talk about the role of the courts in our system, partly because the Supreme Court has become such a, I think, sort of more, um, regressive institution. 40:06 And so I guess I, you know, I-- the, the Democrat in me takes some solace out of what happened in Wisconsin. 40:13 The sort of the, the federal courts nerd in me, um, is just generally happy that state courts are getting more time in the spotlight and that everyone is paying more attention to how we choose state court judges as well as federal court judges because there's a heck of a lot of really important stuff that they do as well. 40:29 It's also part of why what's happening in North Carolina right now is, I think, so significant. 40:34 Um, you know, we have a sort of the North Carolina intermediate state court trying to basically, um, meddle in the s- in the election for the, the, the s- the swing justice on the North Carolina Supreme Court. 40:48 Um, you know, these elections matter for better or worse, and those states elect their judges, and I think the more we're paying attention-- I'll just say, I think that's a net positive no matter what the results are. 40:58 Was the idea of Democratic justices and Republican justices a, a new idea? I mean, it sounds insane as I say it out loud. Um, but, um, w- w- when did that start occurring? Was it just liberal and conservative originally? 41:15 Is that sort of the new words for it, basically? Yeah, I mean, I think also-- I think that's part of it, Jamie. I think also, I mean, the, the parties have sorted, right, in a way that they used to... 41:24 I mean, it, you know, not that long ago, we would talk about conservative Democrats and liberal Republicans. 41:30 Um, you know, there's a great graphic that shows sort of if you plot every member of the House on like an ideological spectrum, in the nineteen sixties and seventies, there's actually a ton of, you know, crisscrossing in the middle, and it just starts sorting and sorting and sorting. 41:45 And I think that the same thing has happened to judges. That, you know, we had... 41:49 I mean, there-- Some of the most impactful so-called liberal justices in the twentieth century were Republicans, or at least were Republican appointees. Um, Earl Warren was a Republican, right? 41:58 William Brennan was appointed by a Republican. Um, David Souter, John Paul Stevens, Harry Blackmun, all Republican appointees. 42:06 So I think part of what happens, Jamie, is like, as the parties have sorted, um, the, the judges have followed suit, so that now, right, as opposed to the old days where you wouldn't just say, oh, there were four Democrats and five Republicans, right? 42:20 Now, liberal and Democrat means not the same thing, but describes the same subset of people the way that conservative and Republican, again, although it doesn't mean the same thing, describes the same subset. 42:31 It's only, Jamie, since twenty ten, only since Justice Kagan was appointed to replace, uh, Justice Stevens, um, that we have seen, um, the Supreme Court for the first time have the ideology of the justices map perfectly onto the party of the president who appointed them. 42:49 And I'll just say, I think in the long term, that's not great. 42:51 Um, you know, I think the, you know, I understand why we now all are so into labeling, but, you know, we should not think lesser of a judicial ruling just because it's from a judge who was appointed by the wrong president, right? 43:03 We should as- we should assess the judges on their own merits and demerits, 'cause there are great judges appointed by presidents of both parties, and there are bad judges appointed by presidents of both parties. 43:14 Um, and the more we can be nuanced about that, I think the better. Yeah. 43:18 I, uh, you know, I'd love to live in a world where you could vote for a Democrat, vote for a Republican, where you just sort of, you know, thought about what made the most sense, and we weren't stuck with these labels, and everybody was crisscrossing in, uh, in the middle. 43:33 Um, and I don't know. We'll, we'll see. 43:35 Maybe there's a world where-We get back to that I mean, Jamie, I, I would have thought that, like, some of the challenges we're facing right now should have been prime examples of that, right? 43:45 I mean, I, I would have thought that the notion that, you know, individuals are entitled to due process before they can be disappeared into El Salvadoran prison would not divide us into Democrats and Republicans, right? 43:56 I would have thought that, you know, the president arrogating the appropriations power to himself would not divide us into Democrats and Republicans. 44:03 And, you know, I think it's unfortunate-- I mean, the, I, I guess the question is, like, you know, how do we, the lawyers especially, try to make the case for that? 44:12 And that's why I think starting from the notion that, like, we should be invested in these kinds of rule of law values regardless of the specific results they produce and regardless of whether, you know, an R or a D wins, I think is-- it has to be part of this conversation. 44:27 Uh, after everybody has signed up and paid for your Substack- [laughs]... then they're going to go and buy your book, Shadow Docket. Um, in that order, everybody. 44:38 Um, but can you talk a little bit, uh, and give people a little bit of the cliff notes of your book and what this sort of idea of the shadow docket, uh, means and these decisions that are being made, uh, that we're not really aware of? 44:53 Sure. I mean, I think, you know, we're aware of them now 'cause, you know, that's all that, that's all we're getting in the news this week. [laughs] Um, so I, I did not coin the term. 45:01 Uh, Will Baude, who's a, a common law professor at the University of Chicago, coined the term in twenty fifteen, um, the shadow docket. He did not mean it pejoratively. 45:08 He meant it as this, like, evocative shorthand, really just to describe, like, everything the Supreme Court does other than the sixty or sixty-five, you know, big decisions and argued cases where we get the big, long rulings in May and June. 45:23 Um, and, you know, Will's insight was that, you know, ninety-nine percent of what the Supreme Court does comes through unsigned and usually unexplained orders, Jamie, through technical stuff that is not unimportant, it's just technical. 45:36 Um, and so, you know, I've been, you know, really sort of resolved to try to help folks understand where these came from, like, how, how the power to use these orders, you know, was both given to and then taken by the Court, um, how it has evolved, Jamie, and, like, what's different about the way that the Court does this today versus twenty, thirty, forty years ago, and it's radically different, really, since twenty seventeen, um, and frankly, why we should be bothered by this. 46:05 Um, you know, it's not the results in any of these cases. Uh, but, like, you know, look at last night, right? 46:10 So the Supreme Court writes maybe two and a half pages, um, to resolve a really complicated dispute over whether challenges to the use of the Alien Enemy Act have to be brought through habeas petitions, through individual cases brought by individual detainees, or whether they can be brought by, you know, sort of these large-scale, class-wide, uh, um, um, organizations. 46:34 Um, that's a huge question. Um, the Supreme Court did not receive briefing, like, full briefing on it. The Supreme Court did not have oral argument on it. The justices resolved it in about four days. 46:44 Um, you know, whatever you think of the results, the, the sort of the basic thesis is that it's not healthy for our legal system for the Court to be doing more and more big stuff through these unsigned and underexplained, if not unexplained, rulings. 46:59 And indeed, um, it's actually a symptom of this broader disease of a Court that just doesn't think it has to explain itself, right? 47:05 So that's the, the basic gist of the book is trying to help folks sort of understand enough about these nerdy technical things that not even, I think, many lawyers fully understand, so that they can, you know, be fa-- uh, have facility in understanding what's problematic about what the Court's doing separate and apart from the bottom lines of the orders it's handing down. 47:25 Got it. Well, thank you for writing that book, and it's must reading for, for everybody who's curious about this topic. Uh, I'm gonna go to a question from the audience. 47:34 Um, Caroline Klimchuk has a, a great question that I'd like her to ask. Hi, um, this is fascinating. My, uh, question is that obviously, as we all know, trust in institutions is at an all-time low. 47:48 Um, why should the American public have faith in the Supreme Court when, you know, it often seems pretty nakedly corrupt? 47:58 And to your point about sort of the nature of the day, I would argue, not to be a pessimist, but the na- the nature of the day seems, you know, opportunism and nihilism. 48:09 How can we rebuild and shore up faith in, um, you know, our institutions? It's a big question. Um, so I, I guess I'll start with, um, you know, I am probably up there in, like, visible critics of the Supreme Court. 48:23 Um, and I criticize the Court a lot because I think it has an obligation to build institutional faith, right? 48:32 I think, I think part of its job is not just to do what five justices think the law is, but actually to build public faith in the Court's credibility writ large, entirely because the Court depends upon us, um, to carry its mandates into effect, right? 48:47 The, the Court doesn't have an army. It depends upon public and political pressure, um, for folks to comply with its rulings. Um, so why should we have faith? 48:56 I, I guess, you know, I, I would go back to the, the Russian proverb that, um, Reagan stole, right? Trust but verify. Um, we shouldn't have blind faith. The Court needs to earn our faith. 49:06 But, you know, not everything the Court does can be chalked up to nihilism and cynicism, um, right? 49:11 So, you know, the first two rulings the Court handed down in Trump cases were both, you know, modest losses, but losses for Trump, um, in the Hampton/Dellinger case and the USAID funding case. 49:23 Um, you know, I think before we're done, even this week, um, Trump's gonna lose a couple of the other pending emergency cases, including the birthright citizenship case, um, right? 49:33 Um, you know, if you wanna go back a little further, I mean, the Court had opportunities in twenty twenty to throw the election to Trump, and it didn't. 49:41 Um, you know, that may seem like a very small, thin reed on which to hang, but I think, you know, these are all signs that the Court is doing at least what the justices view as law.And not just politics. 49:53 And maybe they're not drawing the legal lines where I or you would want them to, but they're still doing something other than just pure politics. 50:00 Um, and to me, I wanna make the case for why they should be doing more of that, um, and why it's important and incumbent upon them to do more of that. 50:09 And I think part of that starts with having a conversation about the Court that is not just, you know, Dobbs bad, um, Obergefell good, right? But that is actually about, like, the Court as an institution. 50:21 How is it weakened as an institution? How can we strengthen it? Why should it be strengthened? Um, and the more that we can find ways in which the Court is part of that story, I think, the better. 50:32 So, you know, I, I don't wanna, I don't wanna sort of sugarcoat this. I think the Court has done plenty in the last few years to undermine public faith. Um, I just think that, one, um, we shouldn't give up all hope. 50:45 Um, and two, um, one of the ways in which we can push the Court to care about this stuff is to help everyone understand why we need a court that is generally credible, um, right? We need a court that... I mean, 51:02 why did Nixon turn over the Watergate tapes, right? You know, the short answer is 'cause the Supreme Court ordered him to. 51:08 Um, the real answer is because if he had defied the Supreme Court, he was guaranteed to be convicted in the Senate, right? 51:15 Um, we need a court that has that kind of support, even from the president's own party in Congress. 51:21 And so this is why it's so important to me to be going out and talking to people about, like, the Court in institutional terms and not just, you know, the Republicans versus the Democrats. 51:30 And that's why I think, you know, that's where we start, and I think that's the conversation that we have to be having, even as we're focused on the individual rulings in the moment. Great. 51:39 That was great, great question, great answer. I'm gonna go to one more question from Greg Chernak. Steve, good to see you again. You too, Greg. Uh, th- thank you for doing this. 51:48 I'm curious on a, a more specific issue, um, how yesterday-- last night's ruling's gonna impact, uh, Judge G- Boasberg's, um, show cause hearing. Can that move forward? 51:59 I know the government filed something last night saying it's all moot now. Normally, that seems to be wrong. 52:05 Um, and I'm also more broadly curious on the idea of the bar itself to take action against some of these lawyers that are taking positions, either misstating things or well beyond that, and whether you think that's a possibility. 52:22 Um, all right, let me take this in order. 52:24 So o- on the, on the very specific question, um, so the, the sort of the, the gravamen of last night's ruling is that the substance of the Alien Enemy Act case, right, should no longer be before Judge Boasberg. 52:36 Um, that doesn't mean there wasn't contempt, um, right? And, and there's actually... 52:41 I mean, Greg, as you know, right, there's a decent amount of precedent out there for the notion that you can commit contempt of court even if the court ultimately didn't have the power to resolve the case, um, right? 52:53 You are-- You can't be saved from contempt by the fact that, like, while you were cursing out the judge, you were making a legal argument that was technically correct, um, right? 53:02 Um, I think the question, Greg, is less about his power and more about what he wants to do. 53:06 Um, and, and it seems to me that if I were Chief Judge Boasberg, um, I would take much the same approach at this point that Judge Dale Ho took in the Adams case, which is, you know, not picking a fight with my appellate brethren over my ability to hang on to a case that I no longer really have, but making a statement for the historical record. 53:27 Um, you know, writing an opinion that says, um, "The government did not show cause. 53:32 You know, I believe that they committed contempt, but because of the Supreme Court's intervention, I'm not gonna actually hold them in contempt." Um, you know, it wouldn't shock me if that's where this ended. Um, 53:42 on the sort of broader question, I, I think we have known for years that the bars of different states have done not nearly enough to hold lawyers accountable for misbehaving, and that's been especially true for government lawyers. 53:56 Um, you know, I, I think it is worth conversations about how to change that. 54:02 Um, and maybe that starts with picking some of the most aggressive misrepresentations we can find from government lawyers, um, and referring them to their local and state bars. 54:12 Um, you know, I'm really sort of nervous about what happened with the sa- with the, the suspension of Erez Reuveni, um, right, for, you know, having the temerity to sort of be candid to the tribunal in the Abrego Garcia case. 54:25 So Greg, I guess my response is, like, I would love to see more aggressive policing by state bars of federal government lawyers. 54:34 There are structural reasons that you know as well as anyone historically why that hasn't happened. Um, but maybe it's time to, you know, to make some, to make some new, some new law on the subject. 54:44 Well, I had a case years ago, uh, in front of Judge Easterbrook where he sent opposing counsel to p- uh, not a government lawyer, but, uh, led to massive problems for this guy who had taken very improper steps. 54:58 I mean, the federal government has at various points taken the position that its lawyers can't be subject to state disciplinary proceedings when they're representing the federal government. 55:06 That just can't be true, um, but it might actually be high time to, to, to establish that, that as a matter of, of, of precedent. 55:14 Just a rapid fire, what are the cases we should be on the, the lookout for in the Supreme Court in the, in the coming months? I mean, I would say in the coming days. 55:23 Um, so what happens in Abrego Garcia I think is really important and will have a lot to-- This is the guy who was wrongly removed to El Salvador and will have a lot to say about just how important the Alien Enemy Act decision was. 55:34 Like, if federal courts can still supervise what's happening even once folks have been removed, I think that mitigates some of the costs. 55:42 Um, I think if the Court doesn't reject the Trump administration's applications in the birthright citizenship cases, that's a really ominous sign, 'cause I think that should have been the easiest case out of all of them for Trump to lose. 55:55 Um, but Jamie, the, you know, the, the sort of the larger point-There are more of these cases coming in this emergency posture. 56:02 Um, and so just folks paying attention to the nerdy technical stuff the court is doing in these cases in lieu of the normal attention we pay to the cases that get the full nine yards of process. Okay. Great. 56:13 Well, thank you for that. 56:14 And then, and then the final thing, obviously, and I, I, you know, I, I don't wanna sound like I'm just your publicist, but obviously signing up for your, your Substack and paying attention to these things. 56:23 I mean, listen, that's the one thing that, uh, Trump has done, is people now care about lower, lower elections that go up and down the, the ballot. 56:33 I mean, people didn't care about those elections or the, the Supreme Court justices. It just wasn't the topic of conversation. Now it's become that. But are there any other things that we can do, the average citizen? 56:43 You know, uh, you know, we can send donuts to the law firms, we can pay attention to elections, but what else can we be really doing? 56:51 So honestly, I mean, I, I really mean this, like, have these conversations with your friends and your family members, right? 56:57 I mean, you know, I have found a, a remarkable amount of disengagement from people who are smart enough to be engaged, and just push on the folks around you to talk about what's happening and talk about why what's happening matters and not let them off the hook. 57:12 Like, that's what we all should be doing no matter what else we're doing in our professional lives. I, I love that 'cause I think that is so important across the board. 57:20 I think I always talk about people, like, if you just do one thing a day, you know, we're gonna reach that world that we're all sort of striving for, and that could be just having a conversation with a friend. 57:29 It could be reading an article. It could be voting. It could be donating money. It could be whatever it is. But if you're just doing something and even having that dialogue, I love that you highlight that. 57:37 Uh, Steve, thank you so much. I know you're, you're burning the candles at both ends right now. Um, hopefully, uh, your students are helping you out in your class maybe. Uh, you need some help and support. 57:47 Uh, don't do it all yourself. And, uh, and I really-- by the way, I... You really are a real Mets fan. As I look through your background there, you have the 1986 poster wrapped up there. You have the OMG sign. 57:58 I mean, you're really... I, I might start rooting for the Mets just to make you happy, so... I, I, I'll take every little thing I can, Jamie. [laughs] Thanks a lot. 58:06 Uh, everybody, we have, uh, Jocelyn Benson coming up soon who's, uh, in our first Meet the Candidates section, who's running for governor. It's a new podcast that I'm gonna be launching. 58:14 And then, uh, Adam Kinzinger will be joining us, uh, the week after. So look out for that. Uh, love seeing everybody. Uh, see you soon. [upbeat music] Thanks for tuning in to this week's episode of Lunch with Jamie. 58:26 As always, be sure to subscribe to my newsletter at jamieslist.com for my thoughts on all things food, pop culture, politics, and more. 58:33 And remember, to join these online conversations and ask my guests questions in real time, sign up to become a paid subscriber. You can listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Audible, and be sure to leave a review. 58:44 Thanks and see you next time. [upbeat music]