Transcript 0:00 [singing] Oh, baby. Welcome to Lunch with Jamie, the series where I sit down with thought leaders and have meaningful conversations about hot button topics with a live virtual audience. 0:13 To participate in these online conversations and be in the room where it happens, subscribe to be a paid member on jamieslist.com. 0:20 You'll also be able to ask questions, participate in the chat, and get up-to-date information from our guests in real time. 0:29 On today's episode, we welcome Anne Applebaum, the Pulitzer Prize-winning historian, staff writer for The Atlantic, and the author of many books, most recently Autocracy, Inc. 0:39 In our conversation, we discuss the Russia-Ukraine war, President Zelenskyy's meeting with J.D. 0:43 Vance and Donald Trump in the Oval Office, the gutting of USAID, her latest book, and why Anne has hope for democratic resilience. 0:52 We also talked about if Elon Musk is actually America's first oligarch, and finally, why Anne thinks nobody should consider leaving America. Hi, everyone. Uh, I want to welcome you to another Lunch with Jamie. 1:06 Uh, today's exciting. We have a handful of new members, which is really critical as we continue to grow and become a more influential community. 1:13 So if you know someone else who might want to join, you can invite them as a guest, uh, or have them sign up to Jamie's list and be a paying member. 1:21 Uh, it has been a couple of crazy weeks since we last met, uh, most notably, obviously, that interview in the-- that, oh, interview in the Oval Office. Uh, I-- Anne Applebaum is our guest today. 1:34 I have been wanting to have her join us for a long time. 1:37 I did not intend to have her join us on maybe the most perfect moment for her to join us, so I'm gonna just, uh, attribute that to luck and the fact that she's always got something very important to say. 1:50 So, uh, Anne, I really want to thank you for joining. A special thank you because I know you are in Poland, and I think it's ten o'clock at night. 1:59 Uh, so thank you for joining us so late, and I also know you have to do another TV appearance after this, so we'll get you off, uh, with a few minutes to spare. 2:06 Um, the, the first thing I wanted to talk to you about is you're in Poland. 2:12 Uh, you are experiencing what it's like to be American on the front lines in a foreign country right now, and I'm just curious to what is the, the vibe, the energy towards the US and towards, uh, Trump and, and also towards that meeting, uh, being there. 2:29 So first of all, thanks for having me. I mean, there is something strange about it being, you know, nighttime here in Warsaw and lunchtime in LA and, you know, I ha-happy, happy to share your lunchtime with you. 2:40 I don't think it's possible to exaggerate how profound the shock of, uh, what's happening is echoing in Europe. 2:51 And just by coincidence, this week I had various little small things I had to do, and I was in Vilnius, and I was in Berlin, uh, and I was in Budapest, and of course, now I'm back in Warsaw, um, over the last few days. 3:03 And everywhere I went, the only thing that people wanted to talk about was the United States and Trump and what's happening, and of course, since Friday, they want to talk about the, the Oval Office. 3:13 Um, it's-- I think the key thing to understand is for Europeans, it's not just about Ukraine. Um, it's really about who they think the United States is and what kind of country is it. 3:26 Um, and here's a-- this is a-- I actually had a, a Hollywood thought, you know, earlier today. I mean, 3:32 the, the, the Americans have a, a kind of good guy-- sorry, Europeans have a kind of good guy, bad guy idea about Americans. 3:39 You know, Americans are friendly and open and, and, and, and, you know, they make mistakes and they get things wrong, but essentially they're well-meaning and they're the good guys, and eventually they defeat the bad guys. 3:50 Um, and they, you know, honor defeats treachery and, and, and, and, and they're well-mannered and e-even if they-- we find them annoying sometimes, you know, we, we feel they're our friends or even almost our cousins. 4:03 Um, that is re-- that is gone, um, shattered in a way that I didn't think could be shattered. 4:08 Um, I think what was really shocking to people about the scene in the Oval Office, which remember followed several other incidents. It followed J.D. Vance's speech in Munich. 4:17 It followed, um, Trump starting to suddenly using Russian propaganda to talk about President Zelenskyy. Um, but the scene in the Oval Office was, it was like a gangster movie. 4:27 You know, it was like suddenly everybody gangs up on the little guy and, um, you know, there was a kind of schoolyard bully attitude. You know, it looked to everybody who watched it as if J.D. 4:38 Vance escalated the argument on purpose. Um, there was something awkward about the atmosphere during the whole thing anyway. 4:46 Um, uh, and s-suddenly it looked like a big country, you know, an, an imperialist power, um, you know, teasing and diminishing a subjugated colony. Um, and that wasn't how anybody thought the United States behaved. 5:02 I mean, uh, maybe they think that way in other parts of the world, but not especially in Europe. Um, and it's a shock. 5:09 Uh, it, it means suddenly rethinking all kinds of assumptions about not just NATO and, and the reliability of the United States in terms of security, but also in economics, in culture, in tech. 5:23 Um, you know, what are our relationships with America? How many of those need to change? 5:26 And I mean, I've had just myriad conversations with all kinds of people asking whether the relationships they've had with Americans in different spheres can continue. Will this be the same kind of world? 5:39 Um, you know, and I mean, I could-- I mean, I don't want to witter on. I mean, I, I, if you, if you want to talk about some of those things specifically, I can. 5:46 But really the profou- the profundity of it was not just Ukraine, as I say. It was this isn't the United States that we thought we knew. It's something different, and now we need to readjust. 5:58 And do you think that relates a lot to just this concept of thinking, as you mentioned, America being our friend and our ally and our big brother or our cousin and this-The, the how hard we worked to no longer be the ugly American, that sort of reference in regards to USAID or, uh, is it something else? 6:17 No, I mean, I think, I think it's, it's, it's, you know, the, the, the random cruelty of cutting USAID and the way that it was cut so that tens of thousands of people might suddenly go hungry or lose their medical care. 6:31 Um, yeah, and by the way, I, I, I spoke to... 6:34 I had several conversations with people over the last two weeks who work there, i- including one woman who is responsible for a refugee feeding program in Africa, and who, as she was talking to me, burst into tears. 6:45 Um, so there's a-- it's a really profound shift. And of course, people see it. I don't know Americans-- I don't know whether Americans are gonna see it, but it will be seen in, in other parts of the world. 6:55 So there's the, the cruelty, there's the, there's the adoption of Russian language when talking about Ukraine. 7:02 You know, this kind of, you know, Zelenskyy's a dictator, um, you know, appearing to put, you know, put, put pressure on Zelenskyy to stop the war, but not Putin. That makes no sense to people. 7:11 I mean, I, I actually-- maybe you want to talk about this in more detail. I still don't know what is the plan to end the war. 7:17 I mean, I get they're pressuring Zelenskyy to stop fighting, but I don't see them pressuring the Russians to stop fighting. So I still don't understand how the war is gonna end. 7:24 Maybe, maybe there's some piece of it I don't know. But the, the cruelty of that, um, the, the brutality of the language and behavior, you know, the, um... 7:34 You know, I mean, we've had that with, you know, that, that's been building for some time. I mean, Trump has a, has that effect on Americans, but also on Europeans. 7:42 I mean, they-- pe-people find that way of speaking and that, that aggression, that insult of enemies, you know, this kind of constant, being constantly on the mo- Being the most aggressive you can be is, is shocking. 7:54 But it's also the sense that, you know, this isn't-- th-there's also the frequent changes of, uh, of policy and of language. 8:03 I mean, actually, Trump was saying very different things about Russia just three or four weeks ago. Um, he was talking about putting pressure on Russia to end the war, actually. 8:11 Um, and so these sudden shifts of policy, and of course, the, the, the tariffs play into that as well, also make people th-- ask, "Well, is this, is this a reliable country? 8:19 Is this somebody who we can do a trade deal with? [chuckles] Is it somebody who we can trust our security with?" And the answer now is, I think, no. Right. Yeah, which is sad. 8:30 And it's so shocking to me the USAID is where they focused on because it was such an-- as the ultimate marketer, it was such an easy thing for Trump to double down on, on not being the ugly American, and, uh, instead they took the opposite approach. 8:43 Um, uh, we obviously have a handful of co-topics we wanna cover today. 8:47 Uh, I-- but I do wanna start, normally don't do things newsworthy, but this post that Trump made on Truth Social this morning, which, um, I, I assume you've seen, which relates to [clears throat] the Tru- the post was all federal funding will stop for any college, school, university allows illegal protests. 9:04 Agitators will be imprisoned or permanently sent back to the country from which they came. American students will be permanently expelled, depending on the crime, and arrested. 9:12 Um, obviously, illegal protests aren't great, but having the federal government starting to meddle in our colleges and our campuses and our schools and churches, universities, where does that fit in the pla- authori-authoritarian playbook, uh, both, uh, you know, internationally, and then how do you think it affects in those, in that playbook being run in the US now? 9:32 So yes, they are running an authoritarian playbook. Um, again, I don't know whether it can seed, but it can succeed, but that is what they're doing. 9:38 I should say that I think that the destruction of USAID wasn't only about USAID, it was also about showing that they can do it. You know, we can destroy a government agency even though it's confirmed by Congress. 9:49 We can take away all its money, um, we can fire everybody, and you can't stop us. 9:53 And I think that was the purpose of it, because then you can intimidate everybody else who works for the federal government, and you can intimidate universities. 10:01 Um, as it happens, I spoke to a president of a large university recently in the last couple of weeks, and they are under enormous pressure. They are under financial pressure. 10:12 They believe that federal funding will be not just slashed, as they've already started to do it for medical research and other kinds of research, but there will-- but it will sooner or later begin to be connected to, 10:26 uh, broadly speaking, DEI, um, maybe to the kinds of programs they have. 10:31 You know, uh, you know, may, you know, maybe if you have a, you have a gender studies program that they don't like, they'll say, "You have to cut that or we'll cut your federal funding." 10:39 I mean, these are the kinds of pressures that they're worried about. And this is something, I mean, that, that, that's a, you know, threatening universities with funding. That was done in Hungary. 10:49 That's done, of course, I mean, it's a matter of course in Russia or China that, that, that universities are controlled. Um, and so that's, that piece they're already worried about. 10:57 Um, and this is, of course, one step further because who decides which kinds of protests are legal and illegal, and isn't that in the university's purview to run their, um, you, you know, to, to, to make those decisions? 11:11 And of course, the implication that protest is illegitimate by, just by definition, um, is, you know, you could start with universities, and then you could begin to apply it more broadly. 11:22 Um, there have been a lot of protests at Tesla offices in the last few days. Uh, what if, what if the federal government decides that Tesla offices protests are also prosecutable? 11:34 Um, you know, if they can make an arbitrary, arbitrary decision about who's allowed to protest and who doesn't in, you know, at a university, then again, they can do it anywhere else. 11:41 But I think the, I think universities are going to be under special pressure, and I've even heard the fear that they may begin to, to fail in some ways very soon. They may have to fire large numbers of people. 11:55 Um, they may start to-- they may have to hedge or change what they're doing very rapidly. 12:00 Um, so I, I, my, my guess is that the federal government is first, the pressure being put under the federal government is now, um, and then the next phase will be universities, and then we may get to NGOs and other things later on.Um, thanks for that. 12:14 Okay, we're gonna, uh, try, try and get into the Ukraine topic and not have it be all the entire conversation. 12:19 Uh, but, uh, you've obviously talked all weekend about this, so I wanna try and get to maybe a couple of things that weren't said or, uh, y- you know, and one place I wanna start with is, you know, you've heard from a couple of people, and you, you know, I think you've talked about it, just in how, uh, Zelenskyy, you know, he did himself no favors by this meeting a- and how he handled himself in this meeting. 12:41 And I had a conversation with someone today where I, you know, I pushed back a bit. Obviously, this guy is f- on the front lines of a war. He, you know, he's walking to a place where they've been supporting Putin. 12:51 It's a, not a great audience. But at the same time, he had a very specific goal of that meeting. Uh, you know, uh, what, what do you... 12:59 What responsibility, I guess, do you put on Zelenskyy for that meeting and how, how it ended? Um, I don't put any responsibility for him on how it ended. 13:07 It ended, it looked to me like it ended the way they wanted it to end. Um, so I'm not sure that was his fault. Uh, um, what, there were t- a couple things that disturbed me about the meeting. 13:17 One was that what really bothered them was him telling them things that are, are true. 13:23 So for example, that Putin has broken lots of, lots of ceasefire deals in the past, which is, which is just true, um, and that he did so the last time Trump was president, which is also true. 13:36 Um, uh, and it, it almost felt like they're living already in an alternate reality where they want the war to end somehow. They don't really care how it ends, but they want it to end. 13:46 Um, and he keeps interrupting them by saying, "No, well, actually, we have this... You know, it's not gonna end if, if the Russians keep attacking us." [laughs] Um, and so I didn't blame him for doing that. 13:57 Um, m- me, you know, maybe you could say he should have not said anything. I mean, it was a strange meeting. It went on for very long. 14:04 Normally, you don't have the press in the room for f- 30 minutes when, when you have a foreign leader there. 14:10 I'm not su- um, but it, but it did also look like the, the moment when it escalates, if you watch the video, was because JD Vance wanted it to escalate. 14:20 Um, he, he was the one who, who started saying, you know, "You haven't thanked us," even when actually if you look at the tape, Zelenskyy thanks them at the very beginning, and he's done so, of course, repeatedly over the years. 14:30 Um, and Vance escalated into, you know, "You're insulting the president." 14:35 Um, and afterwards, they put out all this messaging about Zelenskyy being rude to the president and insulting the president, and then they used it as an excuse to cut off aid. 14:44 And, you know, I, uh, without being remotely conspiratorial, I mean, it does look like they wanted an excuse to cut off the aid, so it may not have mattered that much what Zelenskyy said. 14:55 I mean, of course, maybe he should have talked less. You know, actually, his English isn't perfect. 15:00 You know, I can hear s- he, some mistakes that he makes in English that makes him sound more blunt than he probably means to sound. Um, he should have used an interpreter, for example. That, I mean, why not? 15:10 Um, you know, maybe he shouldn't have said anything at all, but I don't think he did anything that was so grotesque that it merited that extreme response. 15:19 I mean, there's, the, you can't point to a sentence that he said that, that implied that he doesn't respect the United States or he's not grateful to the American people or that he doesn't want the war to end. 15:30 Um, and he put out a, he, you've probably seen he put out a statement this afternoon, um, repeating again that he wants the war to end and he's grateful and, and, a- and so on. 15:40 He's willing to listen to any, to be involved in any conversations. Um, um, so I don't, I, I, it's hard for me to find... 15:49 You could, you could say he did this or that wrong or he should have behaved in a different way or he should have been more flattering or so on, but I can't find anything in his behavior that, that was, that was worthy of that response. 16:01 Yeah, I couldn't agree more. 16:02 Uh, one other thing that something came up wh- when someone I was talking to who is a, a, a big Trump supporter, and as I, uh, mention and talk about all the time, like that's one of my main goals these days is focusing on talking to Trump supporters, con- people with different viewpoints, and they brought up something about just where Zelenskyy stands right now i- in the Ukraine, uh, how... 16:23 A- and as an American and getting our news from MSNBC or CNN or f- you know, wherever else, i- sometimes it's always not, uh, so, um, specific, especially in international cases. 16:35 But, uh, they talked to me about, uh, Zelenskyy, uh, cutting ba- on the television networks, the foreign television networks in Ukraine, and they talked to me about, uh, not holding elections. 16:45 Uh, they talked to me about him, uh, uh, ending, eliminating other political parties. What do, what does it look like if you're a Ukrainian today, as much as you can, on Zelenskyy as your leader? 16:56 To me, he looks like he, he's amazing. 16:58 I mean, I think he's spectacular what he's doing from what I see, but- I, no, no, I mean, I, so to be clear, I mean, I think I've been to s- Ukraine seven times since the war started. I've interviewed Zelenskyy twice. 17:08 Um, um, uh, and I've met many other Ukrainians. I s- I see frequently one or two of his opponents. 17:15 I speak sometimes pretty often to the, when, when I go there, I speak to the mayor of Kyiv, who's, who's a famous rival of Zelenskyy's. 17:22 I've met with Poroshenko, who is a former president, who's a very, even more important rival of Zelenskyy's, so I see a lot of people who don't like him. Um, and I would say, I would say this. 17:32 I would say, first of all, the, the election thing is h- he has unanimous, almost unanimous support. 17:38 Um, the reason they haven't held elections is because, um, the country, people are dispersed and displaced all over the country. They have a million people. Their army's a million people strong. They're all fighting. 17:49 It's not clear how any of those people would vote. How would you have a registered vote? How would you have a vote that was considered to be fair at this moment? 17:57 Um, of course, if you have a big-Activity on a single day or even over a c- two or three days, there would be a risk of people being bombed. Um, the Russians famously attack. 18:06 You know, they're, they look for civic events, and they attack them. Um, so there's no way you could hold an election that would be safe. There's no way you could hold one that would be fair. Um, it... 18:16 Actually, Ukraine's constitution says that when you have martial law, which they have because they're under attack, uh, you don't hold elections. I mean, the UK had the same thing during the World War II. 18:24 They also didn't hold elections. I mean, the United States did, but then we were not under bombardment, you know, either in the Civil War or in any subsequent war, so we- it's not a, it's not a comparable situation. 18:36 Um, so the, the election thing is not controversial. Um, the television, um, there is a, because... 18:42 Again, because of the war, they, they sort of unified the television stations, and they put some restrictions on how much they can report, and they reorganized the TV, and there's some resentment about that. 18:53 There are, um, you know, there are... I, I heard different views. I mean, I heard some people say, "Well, they're..." 18:57 Because of questions of what you can and can't say about the military and what you can and can't say about the conflict, there need to be controls. 19:05 Um, there are, there were people who have found the unification or the, or the, the, the, the working together of journalists on TV very comforting in the first, particularly first couple years of the war, um, when people felt they needed one source of news that was reliable, and they knew it was coming. 19:21 And, um, it's deteriorated a little bit since then, and people are more... grumble about it a bit more. There are other sources of information. There are newspapers. There are journals. There are other, you know... 19:32 There's also, I mean, I, I, I can't stress enough, I mean, there is free speech in Ukraine. [laughs] People argue about stuff. Nobody feels embarrassed or scared to say things. 19:41 Um, you know, the, there are critics of Zelenskyy who speak openly their criticism of Zelenskyy, um, and they're not, you know, they're, they're, you know, it's, it's considered normal, and that I, I, again, cannot stress enough how different that is from Russia. 19:55 I spent many years in Russia. I don't go anymore, obviously. 19:58 Um, but even, even, even 10 years ago, you were, you had a situation where people were afraid to say things in public, where, um, you could pay a very high price for, for opposing, um, opposing Putin or opposing the regime, you know? 20:13 I, I knew Anna Politkovskaya, who was a famous journalist who was murdered. Um, so there was a, you know, th- you know, Ukraine is not a... 20:21 It's a society at war, and there are restrictions because of the war, and some people think those are okay, and some people don't. Um, but there, but it's, but it, it's not, it's not repressive or controlled in that way. 20:32 I mean, there's plenty of, there's plenty of difference of opinion and of view. Um, there is a, there was an investigation of Poroshenko. He's the, he's one of the, he's the former president. Um, he's had some trouble. 20:46 Again, I, I won't repeat to you the various explanations for it. The, Zelenskyy's team have reasons why they will argue that they're looking for... It's legitimate. Obviously, he says it's not legitimate. 20:57 Um, but there are other rivals of, of Zelenskyy's who are happily walking the streets and being critical of him and not having problems. 21:04 So I don't think we have the, the issue in Ukraine is a, is a, is a democratic deficit. 21:10 I mean, I do think that if there was a, if there was a ceasefire tomorrow, they would be happily hold an election, and I even think that Zelenskyy, and we did ask him this on a recent inter- at a recent interview, I think he would, he might even not run. 21:21 I don't, might, maybe he, you know, people change their minds, but I don't think he would be, um, I don't think he's looking to be a dictator or stay in power indefinitely. 21:31 So I have, you know, there are, there are many things to be critical of about him, which is a whole, which is a different subject, but I don't think, you know, especially in this context, in this very bitter and difficult war, when he's fighting a genuinely brutal dictatorship, somebody who, when he occupies Ukrainian territory, arrests and murders people, um, imposes a, a, a totalitarian regime, you know, kidnaps children, um, 21:58 forbids people from speaking their language. You know, when you're up against that kind of pressure and that kind of war, um, you know, in that context, Ukraine is remarkably free and open. 22:08 If I could choose my, uh, former television star leader, I would be definitely choosing Zelenskyy. Uh, let's talk about, uh, NATO for a second. 22:17 You know, to, to me, it seems U- uh, Ukraine entering NATO or other European countries would, would be something supported by all, and it would be something that w- we should want and should happen. 22:28 Uh, obviously, it appears that Ukraine joining NATO at this point is o- is off the table to some extent, almost off the table. 22:37 Um, is that true, and what does that, where does that sort of put NATO kind of going forward and its role and the US's role and support? 22:46 So we're speaking a few hours before Trump's speech, and, uh, s- and I don't know what he's gonna say. 22:53 Um, but he may say something about NATO, so, uh, uh, you know, beware that this might be out of date in, in, in a, in a few hours. 23:02 Um, the issue for Ukraine, I mean, the reason why they want to be in NATO is not because they want, you know, to wear NATO T-shirts and have, you know, Zel- you know, a name, an ambassador with a nameplate, you know, in Brussels. 23:15 Um, the reason they want to be in NATO is that a- whenever the war stops, however it stops, uh, and someday it will stop, um, immediately afterwards, they'll have a, they'll face a, a crisis, and the crisis will be, how do we know it's not gonna start again? 23:32 Um, and there's a real danger that if there's a ceasefire, immediately afterwards, Ukraine will become a kind of failed state because people will say, "All right. The war is over. 23:41 We can go home from the army, um, and now we're gonna get out of this country as fast as possible because the, the war will come back." 23:47 And how will you get people to invest in a Ukraine that doesn't have security guarantees? You know, how will you get people to stay there? How will you get people to come back who, who have left? Um, and w- and when... 23:59 The reason why Zelenskyy keeps returning to this question of having some kind of security guarantee, some-NATO or European or some kind of presence is, is for that. 24:10 Um, because it is true that every ceasefire they've had with Putin has been broken, and they fear that there could be another ceasefire, that Donald Trump could say, "Right, I ended the war," or, you know, "Give me the Nobel Peace Prize," and that it would then start again in six months or six years. 24:26 And, and the, and the, and the NATO issue isn't really about NATO itself, it's about that. It's about how do we know it won't start again? 24:33 How do we get some, some, some guarantee that somebody would intervene, or there would be some other stumbling block or, or roadblock to prevent another invasion? 24:42 So, so I, I think NATO is kind of a red herring actually in, in the, in this context. The issue isn't should Ukraine be in NATO, the issue is how will Ukraine remain safe a-after a ceasefire? Right. 24:55 That's a, a scary thought, and we obviously know Putin has not stayed, uh, honest or stuck to any of his previous ceasefires. 25:03 Uh, I know everybody here has read Anne's book, Autocracy, Inc., cover to cover, memorized it, uh, and bought it for a friend. 25:11 Um, so we know a lot about, you know, uh, the playbooks to, you know, autocratic regimes and how it's worked internationally and, uh, but, uh, two questions for you. 25:24 One, one of the big things is really here is about action and what people can do and how people fight back. Uh, and then two is, y-you-- just in, you know, as a refresher, what are the kind of 25:37 five steps in the, in, in, uh, in, in creating an autocratic regime? What, what is sort of the, the CliffsNotes so that we kind of can all set the table? 25:47 The CliffsNotes, you know, are pretty straightforward, and I should say I've seen it happen in other places. 25:53 I saw we had a government in Poland for several years that also tried to capture the state in, in, in much the way you can see happening in the United States. 26:03 I've s-strangely know a lot of Venezuelans, and I went to Venezuela once, and I've ta- I've, I've spent a lot of time looking at their history and how it happened there. 26:10 This so, this doesn't have to be a right-wing process or a left-wing process. 26:14 Um, what, what, what happened, the, the main way that democracies now fail in most countries nowadays is not because of a coup d'état or s-tanks in the street and a colonel shooting up the chandelier in the, in the president's office. 26:29 Mainly they fail because, uh, an elected leader or an elected political party take power and then, as I say, set out to capture the state. 26:39 That means take all of these neutral institutions that are supposed to be bipartisan or nonpartisan or more, or, or theoretically are nonpartisan, um, and politicize them. And so that would be regulatory agencies. 26:52 That would be, in some cases, courts. In Poland, it was the courts. I think in the US, it's harder to take the courts. Um, it would be, um, inspectors generals. 27:01 I mean, any-anybody who has a job, um, looking in or, or, or establishing transparency. 27:07 Um, sometimes the media, I mean, US doesn't have state media, but there's, that state media is always a focus, um, for those kinds of regimes. 27:14 Um, sometimes it's the private media, so attempts to control the private media through influencing owners or ownership or, or the economics of media so that, so that newspapers or television stations go bankrupt. 27:28 This is what happened in Hungary, um, and are then bought up or taken over by friends of the ruling party or friends of the prime minister. 27:35 Um, so i-in essence, what, you know, when you're elected to, to a political office in a democracy, what you're meant to do, and admittedly this is, this can be difficult for people, is you're supposed to win the job, but then preserve all of these institutions, um, to run the state, um, and to run them neutrally so that there can be a fair election four years later, um, with your, 27:59 you know, with your political rival, and so your political rival can, you know, can maybe defeat you again. 28:04 And so, and the, and there's always been a temptation to try to use the state and the resources of the state to back your own party. 28:12 But w- it is, it is when that happens, when people say, "Right, we're gonna use the state, we're gonna take it over, um, and we're gonna-- and, and, and maybe eventually use it either to make the election unfair or to enrich our friends and comrades, um, you know, or sometimes even block the election," um, that, that's when you have to, that's when you have to worry. 28:32 So look at, watch the, watch regulatory agencies. Watch, uh, the civil service. Watch the media. 28:40 Um, watch, um, you know, judges eventually, uh, because those are-- w-taking over those things can give a political power or leader so much power that he, he's then able to influence or change the, the, the next election. 28:56 Um, I mean, taking over the civil service, by the way, is something that I thought the Trump administration would do, and I wrote about it, and I did a podcast about it in the, in the last summer. 29:06 Um, I didn't expect, I didn't know that it was possible for outsiders to come in and take over the treasury payment system and then to make their own decisions about which programs to cut. 29:19 But that is actually what happened. So we saw, you know, Elon Musk and, and DOGE go into the treasury and say, "We don't like these programs." 29:27 Sometimes they then smeared them online or cherry-picked stories about them to make them look bad, um, and then they cut their funding. 29:35 And this was, these are congressionally funded programs that were legally established by people whom the American, you know, whom Americans voted into office, um, and there is, there was, there was nothing legal about, uh, you know, about that process. 29:49 And that was the first time I've seen state capture happen in that way, so through taking over technology. 29:56 Um, but it, but it, but, but nevertheless, it belongs to this tradition, you know, this tradition of s- I s- you know, the technical term is state capture. Um, and they're doing it. I mean, they're trying it. 30:08 Um, I mean, and, and, um-You know, will they succeed? I don't know. 30:13 Um, we haven't really gotten to the phase of this process where there are court cases that get to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court makes decisions that are, um, opposite to those the Trump administration want. 30:25 And I don't know what's gonna happen at that point. That's gonna be a very, a key turning point. Um, we're, we're close actually. 30:31 Um, we haven't gotten to the point where, uh, enough Republicans in Congress, um, you know, worried that 30:39 universities in their states are, are suffering, or, um, Social Security and, and Medicaid are suffering, uh, you know, and they begin to try to block it through Congress. That hasn't happened yet either. 30:50 Um, maybe we'll get to that stage. Uh, so there are, there are, there are tools that can be used to stop the process. Um, so far nobody's done it effectively. Um, the question of what- 31:03 whatever the rest of us can do, I mean, um, I do see Democrats beginning to organize and beginning to understand what's ha- I think it took... Then this, by the way, is also very typical. 31:13 When there's this, when this kind of autocratic state capture happens, almost always there's immediate disarray in the opposition. 31:22 I mean, I s- I saw that happen here in Poland, I've seen it happen in other countries, um, because the rules of politics have changed. 31:28 You know, so, um, the, the normal ways in which you, in which you conduct, uh, you know, political combat or political debate rather, let's use that term, um, don't work anymore. 31:39 Um, and that's, uh, you know, and then y- and you have a period of chaos, and that, I think that's what we're in now. 31:45 I mean, I'm beginning to see and hear Democrats understand and name what's happening and begin to understand and, you know, explain the consequences to people. 31:54 I mean, if you have a billionaire who is, um, who, who has enormous and complex relationships with the US government, whose companies are funded by US government money, and who then gets control over those agencies that fund him and regulate him, you know, then you're already in a space that I don't think America's ever been in before, where you have a, a proper oligarch, um, who has a kind of power that has, uh, I, I don't think there's a, there's a clear precedent for in the United States. 32:26 And I think it took some time for people to understand that what Elon Musk was doing wasn't just cost-cutting, but it was something much more profound, so, so I'm, I'm cutting people slack on not, not having a, not having a clear reaction. 32:39 Um, if you, as citizens care about this, um, those of you who have platforms, um, I can't see your, your, your, your pictures on the screen, I don't know, you know, uh, um, whether you do or not, but, um, those of you who have platforms should talk about it. 32:53 But, you know, no need to be hysterical or to scare people, but ex- make sure that people understand what's going on because it is something that hasn't happened, at least in the United States at this, at the federal level. 33:04 Before there were sort of earlier versions of it. There's Huey Long in Louisiana. Y- you can find some examples in, in some US states in the past, but we haven't ever had this happen at the federal level. 33:14 Uh, try to understand what's going on, help people explain it. Um, participate as much as you can in any form of local or regional politics. 33:24 Um, you know, for a lot of Americans, national politics is almost like, it's like, you know, you know, TV wrestling. I mean, it's so far away. It involves these big celebrities. 33:35 It's hard, you know, it, it, people don't feel they have any control over it. 33:39 Um, getting people more involved and making real contributions to even school board elections or local or county elections, or, um, local or regional elections, or, um, you know, uh, you know, state elections and state governance in, in our country is actually very, um, in some cases more important. 34:00 It matters more who runs the state than even in sometimes than, than your congressmen or senators because they make a lot of decisions about money and funding and, and the, and, and the way your state is run. 34:09 So the more... You know, or be involved in, in a particular issue or in a campaign. Um, the more you can be involved and the more you can get other people involved, you know, the better chance we have of, 34:22 of coming out, uh, of this on the other end somewhere better. Um, but it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a difficult moment. 34:29 I mean, it, once you follow it and understand it and realize how extreme what's happening is, and again, more extreme than, than what's happened in other countries, um, you know, the right reaction is not to be scared and alarmed and to s- you know, to say, "Oh, I'm, I'm helpless. 34:44 I can't do anything," but to try and think, "What is it, you know, what is my role? How can I, how can I fit into this? How can I do something?" 34:51 And if, if, if lots of people do that, then we will, we will get through it. Uh, uh, that's so well said. Thank you for that. 34:59 You know, I heard a wonderful conversation you had with Jessica Yellin, who's a, who's been on this and, uh, is a close friend. 35:05 And one of the things you guys talked about, uh, is this idea of people leaving, and I hear a lot of people saying that. I'm, have a Can- a wife who has Canadian citizenship and British passports. My kids have them. 35:17 I could leave, uh, probably pretty easily. I'm doubling down now. I love America. I think it's the greatest country in the world. Um, but, 35:27 uh, what, you just l- also laid out a playbook of how an authoritarian regime is being built. Uh, so I guess my question is to you, what are the things that really are gonna start concerning you? We're really seeing... 35:41 I mean, you mentioned violence. Um, but, like, what are the kinda final straws, uh, that you see? 35:48 Oh, I think we're a long way from final straws.Um, uh, uh, you know, there is, you know, we have a, we have an opposition party. We have, you know, free speech. We have, um, you know, we have, you know, people... 36:02 You have access to, to, to the internet and to social media and the airwaves. I mean, there's a... We're n- we're, we're not, um, you know, we're, we're not, we're not Venezuela. 36:11 We have a long way to go before we're, we're that. And I, I really, I, you know, I think it's way too early to talk about leaving. I mean, I, I can't, you know, stand on my high horse here because I'm half and half. 36:22 I, I split my time between, between Poland and the United States. So, uh, it... But I haven't, but I haven't left, and in fact I didn't leave Poland when it was going through its issues either. 36:31 So, um, I suppose the last straw or the thing that you should become worried about is if it becomes clear that elections aren't gonna be fair, if elections will be stolen. 36:42 Um, even that's not the moment to leave, but that's the moment when your civic engagement should be e- even more, um, even more robust. A- and I am worried. Well, we'll see. 36:53 I mean, watch the midterms and then watch, obviously, the next presidential election in four years. I mean, that's a long way away. Uh, I would say that's, that's a change, and I would also, I would worry about... 37:04 I am worried in the medium term, not immediately, but I would worry in the medium term about protests that were then put down with violence. You know, I would worry about that. 37:14 Um, but I, I still think that for, you know, people who, of means and people who have, um, you know, who, who aren't dependent on a, a small federal government salary or even a university salary, I mean, I think there's plenty of opportunity. 37:29 There'll be plenty of things to do here for a long time, so I don't think we're, I don't think we're close to that moment yet. I, I couldn't agree more. Uh, is it fair to say that Elon Musk is America's first oligarch? 37:41 It depends how you use the word oligarch. 37:43 If you mean it broadly to mean rich people, then we've had plenty of those, and if you mean broadly to mean rich people who have influence on politics, then we've had that since 1776. 37:52 I mean, that's not, um, that's not new. 37:55 Um, as I said, what does seem to me new about him is that I don't know of a previous example of someone of that scale of wealth who is now, has access to federal funding, so he's being... 38:08 his companies have federal money, and at the same time has the ability to control the people who make decisions about his money, as well as the people who make decisions about his rivals' money. 38:22 Um, so he is now in a position where he effectively has access to the US Treasury. Um, and that is, that, that is very close to the, what a, what a Russian oligarch is. 38:32 You know, a Russian oligarch is somebody who isn't just a rich person who's influential. He is a rich person whose money is directly related to the state budget, you know? 38:42 He's, he's, he's, he's rich because the leader has allowed him to be rich, and he's rich because he has a way of, of, of making use of state funds or has access to, um, to special treatment. 38:55 Um, and, and that is, that looks like what Musk is becoming. I, I don't know how, I mean, how precarious Musk's position is. I don't know how long he's gonna be there. 39:04 I don't know whether there's gonna be a backlash against what he's doing, but certainly what he's doing right now, and I said this already but I'll say it again, it doesn't have a precedent that I know about, that I'm, that I'm aware of. 39:14 I mean, I know there have been, there have been businesspeople in the government before. That's happened. 39:19 Um, but the scale of this and the power that he has and the ability that he seems to have to make decisions about, uh, American government programs, whether it's the Park Service, you know, as well... 39:32 It's not just USAID. It's the Park Service and the Department of Agriculture, and the, you know, the people who measure the weather and all kinds of institutions all across the country. 39:42 He is able to make s- um, decisions about whether those, those programs should exist or not exist based on his personal whim. Um, that I, that I can't think of anything else like that. 39:55 So yeah, I would call him in that sense an, an, an oligarch. Yeah. Um, okay. We're gonna go, uh, to a question. Uh, first from Greg, uh, Chernak, who has a question about China. Hi, Cass. Thank you, Jamie. 40:10 And, uh, and thank you for doing this. I'm curious your views on how Beijing is responding to all of this, particularly vis-à-vis Taiwan. Um, is this something the Taiwanese are freaked out about? 40:21 Should they be freaked out right now, or do you think Xi is willing to sort of exploit this, sit back as the US hurts itself internationally, and is able to exploit, um, its, uh, its initiatives with, uh, USAID withering away, and can exploit all this internationally in a way, and take advantage of what Trump is doing to the US internationally? 40:46 Oh, I'm sure China's very happy to take advantage of what Trump is doing internationally, and I'm sure that will happen, and you'll see the Chinese walk into places we've abandoned, and so on. 40:56 Um, I am worried about Taiwan, and the Taiwanese are worried about Taiwan, um, um, because they saw and China saw and actually a lot of the rest of the world saw Ukraine as a kind of precedent, you know, that if we were willing to defend Ukraine, then that at least gave China a sort of, you know, a reason to think twice about invading Taiwan. 41:20 I mean, they were... The, the situations aren't exactly the same, but there's enough parallel, um, that people understood it, and that, that, that certainly the Taiwanese understood it. 41:28 And actually, the Chi- Taiwanese are very supportive of Ukraine. Um, and there were a lot of Taiwanese Ukrainian contacts over the last couple of years that I, that I know about. Um, so yes, I, I think... 41:39 I, I, I doubt China would, will do anything very fast because that's not really their style. Um, 41:45 maybe there's one other important thing to say about China, is that I know there are people in the Trump administration who are saying that-Trump bringing America closer to Russia, maybe even aligning with Russia, is they're calling it a reverse Kissinger. 41:58 You know, that instead of, you know, Kissinger making a special deal with China, they're gonna make a deal with Russia and therefore cut out China. This is, this is really extraordinarily naive. 42:08 I mean, I, and I, I, I, I don't know whether any serious people believe it. I mean, first of all, the Kissinger negotiations with China were secretive over many months. 42:17 There was, you know, they were, they were careful and cautious and well-prepared, and this is exactly the opposite. 42:22 But more importantly, you know, the, [laughs] the Russian economy is totally dependent on the Chinese economy. Um, you know, the Russians are, um- you know, cannot... 42:32 You know, their, their war effort wouldn't function if it wasn't for Chinese components as well as, of course, North Korean soldiers and, and Iranian drones. 42:40 Um, China and Russia, Xi and Putin actually have an enormous amount in common in the way they think about the world and w- in their understanding of the danger that liberal democratic ideas pose to their societies. 42:52 This is one of the subjects of my book. Um, there is no way they're gonna break up. [laughs] Um, that's not happening. Um, so I- if, if people really believe that, it's a, it's, it's, it's a naive belief. 43:04 I mean, I think more, more likely what will happen is the Chinese will watch and wait and see and then try to take advantage of the situation. 43:11 I mean, one other way they might take advantage, if, if there, if there's a lot of turbulence in the US economy, um, and maybe there will be, and some, some people believe there could be, then they may try to 43:24 replace the dollar as the world currency. I mean, then there are, there are other kinds of bigger games you could watch them playing. 43:30 I mean, I'm not saying that will happen, but it's, we know they think about it, and we know they have... 43:35 They're, they're preparing for some kind of moment of chaos when they can replace the United States in bigger ways, not just in terms of, you know, providing aid in, in Africa. Thank you for that. 43:49 Uh, Anne, we know we're only 43 days into the administration. We're gonna have the State of the Union tonight, but can you explain the, the Trump foreign policy today? I mean, if you had to 44:02 teach a class on it right now, w- what, is there a way to? 44:07 Based on his language and the things that he's said so far, and stipulate that he could change, he, he changes frequently and sometimes very dramatically his, his policies, um, Trump is resurrecting the idea of a kind of 19th century or even 18th century imperial power. 44:25 You know, he has the idea that he, that, that the network, the 80-year-old network of alliances that the United States built through which it exercised a very unusual kind of power, it was a power of influence, um, um, but it, it, it, it, it gave the United States a special role in the world. 44:42 He's very happy to destroy that and instead use American power to push, you know, to, to, to bully people essentially, um, you know, to, to put tariffs on Mexico, to, um, you know, to, to, to bully Ukraine, maybe eventually to, to, to force Europeans to... 45:01 I don't know. He has this thing about Mercedes cars, I don't know, to make them not export cars to New York so that they don't bother him when he sees them. Um, but, but he, he, he has a, he has a, a... 45:11 He's thinking like a, you know, an imperial power, that when he wants something, he can take it. 45:17 He can demand Greenland, he can demand Panama, he can demand Canada, um, and that he doesn't have to take into consideration the, the, the, again, the alliances, the rule of law, um, the international law, um, any of the, any of the, the, the, the diplomatic rules, um, the real rules and the norms that have been set up over the last, uh, as I said, 80 years. 45:41 Um, he, he wants the US to be more like Russia or more like China. You know, he wants it to be a kind of brutal power that takes things. 45:50 What confuses me about this, I mean, I can see him doing that, and I understand that, you know, that's the language he's using. I don't really understand what he thinks he will get. 46:00 I don't understand what the end game is. I mean, does he just want to expand the US on the map and add Greenland? I'm not sure how that helps us. You know, anything that he wants to do in Greenland, he can do now. 46:12 He can have a minerals treaty with Greenland tomorrow. He can have, uh, six more military bases in Greenland now. I mean, we have, we have base there already. 46:20 I mean, actually, in the, in the, in the 1950s, we had nuclear weapons, and we stored them in Greenland in, e- even though it was illegal under Danish law. So we can, we can do what we want there. 46:30 Um, I'm not sure why we need to own it. Um, and so I'm not, I also don't understand how he imagines that this kind of policy will bring greater prosperity to Americans. That also confuses me. 46:41 I mean, maybe there's a, there's a piece of it that I don't understand, but, you know, what, what did US power do over the last eight decades? 46:48 It created these big zones of trade, um, and free movement and prosperity, mostly in Europe and Asia, in the, among the European democracies and the Asian democracies. 46:59 Um, and, and Americans, you know, um, had huge access to those markets and, um, huge access to the people who lived in them. There was a free exchange of ideas in those places, and it made us really powerful. 47:13 It made us the most powerful country in the world. 47:15 If we're gonna eliminate those things, and we're not gonna provide security, and we're gonna treat those countries as enemies rather than friends, I don't know what the advantage is to us. I genuinely don't. 47:25 [laughs] Um, but maybe we'll see. Maybe they have a, maybe they have an explanation that I haven't heard. Thank you for that. 47:33 What do you think, um, the, the future is now for authoritarian regimes, uh, across the world, and, and how scared are you, and is there any hope that you're seeing in different countries that you could point to for us?Authoritarian regimes have over the last decade or so begun working together in new ways. 47:52 And again, that's the subject of my book. Um, you know, they, they, they created an authoritarian narrative. 47:58 They looked for allies inside the US and, and, and Europe and elsewhere, um, and they tried to, um, create a world in which basically what they were most afraid of were the liberal ideas and the democratic ideas and the ideas about freedom or about rights that they heard coming from their own people. 48:17 And so to crush the aspirations of their own people, they real- they came to realize they needed, um, to control the way these ideas are used around the world. Um, and they'll keep doing that. 48:27 They, they, they don't always win. Um, 48:31 s- you know, I mean, w- because it's been completely buried by other news, we've all rather forgotten about Syria [laughs] which was-- that was a regime that had been in place for fifty years. 48:39 Um, it was backed by two other aut- autocracies. It was backed by, uh, by Russia and Iran, um, you know, who kept their military going and kept their economy going until they, until neither one of them could. 48:51 Actually, it was a side effect of the war in Ukraine in some ways, as well as the war in Gaza, um, that Russia didn't have the ability anymore to prop up the Syrian regime. 48:59 Um, and when it fell, it fell almost instantaneously because it was so deeply unpopular and because even the people who were working for it and fighting for it just didn't want to defend it anymore. 49:12 I mean, it wasn't overthrown by a successful military operation. It was overthrown because people stopped defending it. 49:20 Um, and that scenario is one I can imagine in other places, um, the, the, where the, you know, when the regime runs out of money, when it runs out of, um, you know, when it, when it loses its support, it will collapse. 49:33 I mean, one, you know, one of the advantages democracies have historically had over dictatorships is that we have a predictable way of changing power and of, and of, um, you know, we have, we have, we have more s- in that sense, we're more stable. 49:49 Um, whereas, uh, you know, dictatorships, when you have a moment of change of power or when you have a, a moment when the autocrat is weak, you can have very rapid collapses and, and shifts. 50:00 Um, and so there, there, and there's plenty of scope for [laughs] that still to happen, um, in, you know, in, in, in dictatorships around the planet. 50:08 I wouldn't-- I, maybe I should finish by saying I wouldn't underestimate, i-including in our own country, um, the power of democratic ideas, you know, the power, the belief in freedom, the belief in rights. 50:22 Um, it is-- I, I often hear those ideas coming from people who, who don't even, who don't even know them from books. I mean, I, I'll give an example. I was in Sudan, actually. Um, uh, I mean, I'm, 50:36 I, it's a, I haven't written about it yet, but I will eventually. I was in a, a place where there-- people had no particular reason to know anything about the history of democracy, um, because how would they? 50:45 I mean, they live in a place where, um, you know, the, 50:50 the, there's a civil war and, you know, and before that there were dictatorships and, and yet you s- people intuitively understand, you know, they intuitively understand that a politicized court is a bad court. 51:00 You know, courts should be neutral. They should, they should decide on the basis of justice. They intuitively understand that media that's controlled by the state isn't real media. 51:08 It's not real information, you know, and they know not to trust it. Um, they immediately understand the idea that individuals should have, should have rights to things. They should be able to say what they think. 51:20 They should be able to meet with whom they want. I mean, these are, these are ideas that bubble up from the ground almost. Um, even in, even in the worst places on the planet, uh, you can hear them. 51:31 Um, and so, so I wouldn't underestimate ever the power of those things because people, people come to them even when they aren't trained. 51:39 You know, you don't need a democracy promotion program for people to come up with the idea that cit-citizens, people in a country should have some influence over how their government works. 51:49 Um, and so I think w-however bad it gets anywhere, you know, uh, in, you know, in, in the US or anywhere else, those ideas will always have an appeal. Uh, that's great. 52:00 Um, I'm gonna let you go in, uh, just a couple minutes. 52:02 Uh, but you remind me, uh, of just how critical my day job is when we talk about our soft power and how, you know, us and, you know, America and around the world can get these ideas out through movies, TV shows, music, you know, uh, uh, books a-a-across the board and how important that is. 52:19 Uh, Anne, I wanna thank you so much for, for joining. Uh, everybody, uh, please go buy another copy of Autocracy, Inc. for their friend. Uh, join The Atlantic. 52:29 Uh, there's a, a s- a link in the chat to, uh, get a, a discounted subscription and sign up for Anne's Substack. Uh, Anne, where can we go see you in five more minutes? Where, where, where are you, where are you on next? 52:40 [laughs] Uh, Nicole Wallace's program. [laughs] Okay, good. All right. Well, thank you. 52:44 For no doubt I'm gonna say exactly the same things, but- No, you're, this is- I'll try, but then I have to do sound bites, so I'll be- Oh, yeah... I'll just be shorter. Okay. 52:50 Well, please get some sleep and keep doing your extraordinary work. Uh, you are a force and a critical voice that we need, and we appreciate you being here and, uh, doing the work you do. So thank you. Thank you. 53:03 [outro music] Thanks for tuning in to this week's episode of Lunch with Jamie. As always, be sure to subscribe to my newsletter at jamieslist.com for my thoughts on all things food, pop culture, politics, and more. 53:15 And remember to join these online conversations and ask my guests questions in real time, sign up to become a paid subscriber. You can listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Audible, and be sure to leave a review. 53:26 Thanks, and see you next time. [outro music]